Philosophical defenses -- The case for indirect realism / Harold I. Brown -- Illusions and hallucinations as evidence for sense data / E.J. Lowe -- Experience and representation / William S. Robinson -- Qualia realism : its phenomenal contents and discontents / George Graham and Terence Horgan -- The world of qualia / Matjaž Potrč -- Subjective physicalism / Robert J. Howell -- Scientific defenses -- Color qualities and the physical world / C.L. Hardin -- Heat, temperature, and phenomenal concepts / Isabelle Peschard and Michel Bitbol -- A process-oriented view of qualia / Riccardo Manzotti -- The ontological status of qualia and sensations : how they fit into the brain / John Smythies -- Attacks -- The churchlands' war on qualia / Mark Crooks -- Why Frank should not have jilted Mary / Howard Robinson -- Phenomenal knowledge without experience / Torin Alter -- A defense of qualia in the strong sense / Barry Maund -- How to believe in qualia / Amy Kind -- Transparency and the unity of experience / John O'Dea -- Phenomenal character and the transparency of experience / Martine Nida-Rümelin -- From the looks of things : the explanatory failure of representationalism / Diana Raffman -- Why transparency is unethical / Edmond Wright.